Born Michael Ilyinsky, Fr. Michael was a member of the faculty of St. Platon's Seminary in Tenafly, New Jersey, at its founding and became its rector prior to its closing in 1923. (Tarasar, 134, 334).
As an archpriest, Fr. Michael in 1934 in the midst of the reaffirmation of "temporary self-government" by the Metropolia at its 5th All-American Sobor suggested that a delegation be sent to Moscow to explain this status, though his suggestion met with no support.
On October 13, 1935, Fr. Michael was consecrated Bishop of Boston under the monastic name Makary. In 1937, Bp. Makary was appointed Bishop of Brooklyn and was also named rector of the newly established St. Vladimir's Seminary in New York. (ibid., 334)
In 1937 at the Metropolia's 6th All-American Sobor in New York City, where a decision was made to renew relations with the ROCOR (See: ROCOR and OCA), Bishop Makary "gave as his opinion that the commitment to the agreement was more in the nature of a moral than an administrative agreement" (Surrency, 46).
In January of 1946, along with Bishop Alexey of Alaska, Makary broke from the Metropolia and was united to the Church of Russia as a result of the Metropolia's continued support of the ROCOR and its distancing of itself from Moscow (ibid., 54). Makary's act was met with an anathema by the Metropolia, which Moscow called on the Metropolia to withdraw in 1947 as it named Makary as Archbishop of New York and Patriarchal Exarch of All America and Canada (ibid., 58).
|Bishop of Boston (Metropolia)|
|Bishop of Brooklyn (Metropolia)|
|Patriarchal Exarch of All America and Canada (Russian)|
- Surrency, Archim. Serafim. The Quest for Orthodox Church Unity in America (1973), pp. 5, 7, 44, 46, 54, 58-59, 121
- Orthodox America 1794-1976 Development of the Orthodox Church in America, C. J. Tarasar, Gen. Ed. 1975, The Orthodox Church in America, Syosett, New York